What Does Cuttlefish Taste Like?

The cuttlefish is a close relative of the squid and octopus, offering a blend of mild sweetness and a hint of the ocean, making it a favorite in many cuisines worldwide.

Imagine biting into a piece of cuttlefish. The first thing you notice is its tender, slightly chewy texture. Then, the subtle sweetness hits your palate, followed by a rich, creamy flavor that’s reminiscent of its cephalopod cousins yet distinctively it’s own.

Intrigued? In this article, we’ll delve deeper into the taste of cuttlefish, exploring its unique flavor profile, how it’s used in various dishes, and why it’s a must-try for any seafood lover.

How Does Cuttlefish Taste?

Cuttlefish taste is often likened to that of squid but with a richer, creamier undertone that sets it apart. The texture is tender yet slightly elastic, a characteristic trait of cephalopods, providing a satisfying chew that seafood enthusiasts love.

What Does Cuttlefish Taste Like

When cooked properly, cuttlefish can take on a buttery, nutty flavor that complements a variety of dishes.

Whether it’s grilled to perfection, simmered in a hearty stew, or served raw in delicate sushi, cuttlefish imparts a subtle sweetness that enhances the dish’s overall taste.

Moreover, cuttlefish ink, a prized ingredient in many Mediterranean and Asian cuisines, adds a distinct briny flavor and dramatic black color to dishes like pasta and risotto. It’s an ingredient that not only elevates the visual appeal of a dish but also adds depth to its flavor profile.

Does Cuttlefish Smell Fishy?

When it comes to cuttlefish, you might be wondering if it carries that strong, fishy smell often associated with seafood. The answer is not really.

Fresh cuttlefish have a mild, ocean-like scent that’s far from overpowering. It’s a smell that’s reminiscent of the sea but without the intense fishiness that can sometimes be off-putting.

raw cuttlefish inked at market

This subtle aroma plays a significant role in the overall taste experience of cuttlefish. The scent of the sea that it carries enhances its mild, sweet flavor, creating a harmonious balance between taste and smell.

This is particularly noticeable when cuttlefish is served raw or lightly cooked, where its natural aroma can shine through.

However, like any seafood, if cuttlefish starts to give off a strong, unpleasant odor, it’s likely, not fresh and should be avoided.

What Does Cuttlefish Compare With?

If you’re trying to imagine what cuttlefish tastes like, it can be helpful to compare it with some other familiar seafood:

  • Squid: Cuttlefish can be compared to squid. They have a similar mild, sweet flavor and chewy texture. However, cuttlefish have a richer, creamier taste.
  • Octopus: Both cuttlefish and octopus belong to the cephalopod family. They share a similar texture, but the octopus has a stronger, more robust flavor than the cuttlefish’s subtle sweetness.
  • clams: While clams are not a cephalopod, their sweet, ocean-like flavor is somewhat similar to that of cuttlefish. However, clams have a softer texture and a more pronounced brininess.
  • Scallops: Scallops share cuttlefish’s sweet, delicate flavor profile, but their texture is much softer and less chewy. If you enjoy the sweet flavor of scallops, you’ll likely enjoy cuttlefish as well.

How To Eat Cuttlefish

Cuttlefish can be prepared in a variety of ways, each method bringing out a unique aspect of its flavor and texture. Here are some popular ways to enjoy cuttlefish:

Grilled Cuttlefish

grilled cuttlefish cooking

Grilling is a popular method of preparing cuttlefish, especially in Mediterranean cuisine. The high heat of the grill caramelizes the surface of the cuttlefish, enhancing its natural sweetness and adding a delightful smoky flavor.

Grilled cuttlefish is often served with a squeeze of fresh lemon and a drizzle of olive oil, allowing the simple, fresh flavors to shine.

Cuttlefish in Pasta and Risotto

In Italian cuisine, cuttlefish is often used in pasta and risotto dishes. Its mild, sweet flavor complements the creamy, rich sauces typically used in these dishes. One famous example is “risotto al nero di seppia,” a black risotto colored with cuttlefish ink. The ink adds a unique briny flavor and dramatic color to the dish, making it a standout on any menu.

Raw Cuttlefish in Sushi and Sashimi

In Japanese cuisine, raw cuttlefish is often used in sushi and sashimi. The cuttlefish’s tender, slightly chewy texture, and subtle sweetness make it a perfect match for the vinegared rice in sushi.

When served as sashimi, the cuttlefish is typically thinly sliced and served with a simple dipping sauce to highlight its fresh, ocean-like flavor.

Braised Cuttlefish

Braising is another excellent way to prepare cuttlefish. This slow-cooking method makes the cuttlefish incredibly tender and allows it to soak up the flavors of the braising liquid. Braised cuttlefish can be served as a main dish or used as a flavorful addition to stews and soups.

How To Buy Cuttlefish

When buying cuttlefish, there are a few key things to keep in mind to ensure you’re getting the best quality. Whether you’re at a grocery store, a seafood market, or considering ordering it at a restaurant, here’s what you need to know:

raw cuttlefish

Other Names

Cuttlefish are sometimes sold under different names. In Italian cuisine, it’s often referred to as “seppia,” especially when its ink is used in dishes like pasta and risotto. In sushi restaurants, you might find it listed as “ika,” which is the Japanese word for squid but is often used to refer to squid and cuttlefish.

Freshness is Key

The most important factor when buying cuttlefish is freshness. Fresh cuttlefish should have a mild, ocean-like scent. If it smells strongly fishy or unpleasant, it’s likely, not fresh. The flesh should be firm and spring back when touched, not mushy or slimy.


Cuttlefish should have a healthy, shiny appearance with clear, bright eyes. The skin should be smooth and moist, not dry or wrinkled. If you’re buying whole cuttlefish, look for intact ones with no visible damage or discoloration.

Buying from a Restaurant

If you’re new to cuttlefish and want to try it at a restaurant first, look for places that specialize in seafood or Mediterranean and Asian cuisines, as these are the cuisines where cuttlefish is most commonly used. Ask the server for their recommendations on dishes that highlight cuttlefish’s unique flavor and texture.

Remember, the quality of the cuttlefish you buy will greatly influence the taste of your dishes, so it’s worth taking the time to choose the best you can find.

Cuttlefish FAQs

How is cuttlefish different from squid in terms of taste and texture?

While cuttlefish and squid are similar in many ways, some key differences exist. Both have a mild, sweet flavor, but cuttlefish have a richer, creamier taste. Both are tender and slightly chewy, but cuttlefish is often described as having a slightly firmer texture than squid.

How do you prepare and cook cuttlefish?

Cuttlefish can be grilled, where the smoky flavor from the grill enhances its natural sweetness. It can also be used in pasta and risotto dishes, often with its ink to add a unique flavor and dramatic color. In Japanese cuisine, raw cuttlefish is used in sushi and sashimi. It can also be braised, which makes it incredibly tender and allows it to soak up the flavors of the braising liquid.

What does cuttlefish ink taste like?

Cuttlefish ink has a unique briny flavor that adds depth to dishes. It’s often used in Mediterranean and Asian cuisines, particularly in pasta and risotto, where it imparts a dramatic black color and a distinct, ocean-like flavor.

Why should you choose to eat cuttlefish over other seafood?

Cuttlefish offers a unique taste and texture experience that differentiates it from other seafood. Its mild, slightly sweet flavor and tender, slightly chewy texture make it a delightful alternative to more common seafood like shrimp or fish. Plus, it’s versatile and can be used in various dishes, from grilling to sushi, making it a fun and interesting ingredient to experiment with in the kitchen.

About Justin Micheal

Hey, I’m Justin and the home cook behind Food Meets Flavor. I have a passion for cooking and making food delicious. So, I started this blog to help others understand what different types of food taste like and how to make everyday meals taste even better.